Central bankers and new banking paradigms: Dialogue with Andrea Enria
YSI Dialogue with Andrea Enria (SSM)
January 2020 - December 2020
Webinar series in preparation for Young Scholars dialogue with Andrea Enria
Webinar Series
Description
This webinar series aims to provide young scholars with an overview of some of the most important debates around central banking and the main changes affecting the banking sector. The purpose of these webinars is to critically explore the challenges faced by central bankers and supervisors, in preparation for our dialogue with Andrea Enria, Chair of the Supervisory Board of the European Central Bank, which will take place in Frankfurt, on 27 April 2020. The sessions will tentatively cover the following topics: central banking culture and ethical implications; challenges emerging from new banking paradigms; historical aspects related to the euro formation and early supervisory arrangements. At the end of each session, we will summarise the main takeaways, and extract possible questions to be asked to Dr Enria.
These series are open to anybody with interest in the topic; however, those young scholars willing to apply and take part in the Frankfurt dialogue, should attend at least 3 of the 4 planned sessions, as it is fundamental to have some background information and preparation ahead of our meeting.
UPCOMING EVENTS
There are no upcoming events in this project.
PAST EVENTS
Webinar
Online13 Feb 2020
Identifying and Remedying Deferential Norms in Prudential Cultures
The Finance, Law, and Economics and Political Economy of Europe working groups are thrilled to announce the first webinar in our series in preparation for our meeting with Dr Andrea Enria, Chair of the Supervisory Board of the ECB. This kick off session is entitled "Identifying and Remedying Deferential Norms in the Prudential Cultures for Regulating Banks and Other Financial Firms in Particular Areas of the World", and will be hosted by Edward Kane (Boston College). The aim of this first session is to critically assess the cultural differences in rule enforceability in the supervisory domain, in order to extract specific questions that we would like to address to Dr Enria.More concretely, the session will examine the substantial literature comparing differences in the formal structure of financial rules that apply in different countries, and will focus on the little work that compares differences in the cultures surrounding their enforceability. Understanding the norms of a country's regulatory culture is important if one is trying to predict how governments will respond to actual-- as opposed to hypothetical--crisis pressures. The session will critically explore the assumptions beyond rule enforcement by focusing on US and EU policy makers, and the consequences that these assumptions have on the way crisis are handled. Finally, the session aims to foster research that goes beyond comparisons between formal differences, to work that focuses on actual cultural enforceability dimensions.
Learn moreWebinar
Online3 Mar 2020
Digital Banking Ecosystem: The Challenges Ahead
The Finance, Law, and Economics and the Political Economy of Europe working group are glad to host the second webinar in preparation for our meeting with Dr Enria in Frankfurt, on April 27. This second session "Digital Banking Ecosystem: The Challenges Ahead" will be presented by Giuseppe Colangelo (Jean Monnet Professor of European Innovation Policy), and it aims to critically explore the main aspects concerning the new banking paradigm introduced by 'Open Banking'. The webinar will particularly focus on the increasing importance of data protection and data ownership, and the role of third parties in the Open Banking domain; the risks and benefits for consumers deriving from the broader offered by these new actors; and competition issues between incumbents, Fintech e Bigtech. The ultimate aim of this session is to critically explore the challenges that these transformations pose to the role played by supervisor and policy makers, and to extract the most fundamental questions that we would like to ask Dr. Enria in our meeting, in connection to banking and new technologies.
Learn moreWebinar
Online14 Apr 2020
Paul Volcker and the Transformation of Finance
New date announced! The Finance, Law, and Economics, and the Political Economy of Europe working groups are happy to host the third webinar from the series in preparation to our meeting with Andrea Enria, Chair of the Supervisory Board of the ECB (which will be rescheduled according to the developments in the Covid-19 situation).The third webinar, "Paul Volcker and the Transformation of Finance" will be hosted by Robert Johnson (President, INET) and Gaurav Vasisht (Senior vice president and Director of financial regulation initiatives, The Volcker Alliance). Paul Volcker has been a policymaker and an intellectual force behind the evolution of the financial systems since the 1970s. As the president of the Fed, he propelled a process of market deregulation with far reaching consequences, but later in life, when he thought a limit had been reached, he made influential calls for moderation.Robert Johnson and Gaurav Vasisht will discuss the political and economic context in which Volcker's journey unfolded, the crucial decisions made, as well as the economic theories that inspired it. This third webinar will be crucial to better understand both technical and historical aspects surrounding the transformation of financial regulation, and will help us sharpen our discussion agenda and questions to be posed to Dr Enria during our dialogue.We look forward to seeing you online!
Learn moreWebinar
Online24 Jun 2020
When Things Don’t Fall Apart - Global financial incoherence and beyond
We are glad to announce our forth webinar in the series 'Central bankers and new banking paradigms: Dialogue with Andrea Enria'. Although our event had to be suspended, we decided to continue with the webinar series in order to keep on exploring interesting topics related to the global financial architecture. We are thrilled to have Prof Ilene Grabel with us, who will present her latest book and provide us with further reflections on financial governance in the era of Covid-19. When Things Don’t Fall Apart: Global Financial Governance and Developmental Finance in an Age of Productive Incoherence (The MIT Press, 2017) won the 2019 European Association for Evolutionary Political Economy Myrdal Prize, the 2019 Int'l Studies Association International Political Economy Best Book Award, & the 2018 British Int'l Studies Association International Political Economy Book Prize. Open access edition of the book available at: https://direct.mit.edu/books/book/3634/When-Things-Don-t-Fall-ApartGlobal-Financial In When things Don’t Fall Apart, Ilene Grabel makes a simple but controversial claim, based on the work of the eminent social scientist Albert O. Hirschman. Grabel argues that as concerns global financial governance and development finance we are now in a period that she calls productive incoherence. Unlike the Keynesian period of the middle 20th century and the neoliberal period that followed, the current conjuncture lacks an overarching theoretical framework to guide financial governance. In its absence, Grabel maps the proliferation of institutional innovation at the national, regional, and transregional levels. These experiments are grounded in a spirit of Hirschmanian pragmatism rather than Keynesian or neoclassical dogmatism. They are ad hoc, often limited in scope, and even inconsistent with each other. They are in that sense incoherent. The book’s novel normative claim is that this incoherence is productive. It is allowing for new institutional and policy innovations that are contributing to a pluripolar financial governance architecture that is more robust and offers greater opportunities for problem solving and experimentation than the coherent architecture it is displacing. Grabel substantiates these claims with empirically-rich case studies that explore the effects of recent crises on established and new networks of financial governance (such as the G-20); transformations within the IMF; institutional innovations in liquidity support and project finance from the national to the transregional levels; and the “rebranding” of capital controls. Grabel acknowledges, however, that the incoherent transformations underway also pose grave risks. She considers these risks in the concluding chapter of the book. Grabel will also reflect on the constructive and destructive aspects of incoherence in the global financial arena in the era of Covid-19. Speaker's short bioIlene Grabel is a Distinguished University Professor at the University of Denver and Professor of International Finance at the Josef Korbel School of International Studies of the University of Denver (USA). She co-directs the graduate program in Global Finance, Trade, and Economic Integration at the Korbel School. Her research and teaching interests focus on the political economy of international financial policy, institutions, and financial flows; global financial governance; global, regional, and transregional financial architectures; and finance and economic development. See more of Prof Grabel's journal articles, book chapters and working papers here: https://ilenegrabel.com/journal_book_papers/ For those that would like to participate but are not currently registered in the Young Scholars Directory, feel free to contact cecilia.delbarrio@unitn.it to get the link ahead of the event. We look forward to seeing you online! Orsola, Stefano, and Cecilia
Learn moreData, Innovation and Competition in Finance: Access to Account Rule
Working Paper
Authors: Oscar Borgogno and Giuseppe Colangelo Title: Data, Innovation and Competition in Finance: The Case of the Access to Account Rule Abstract: Technological innovation can foster competition within the retail financial sector. However, in order to pave the way for the emergence of FinTech with the goal of promoting innovation and competition, policymakers need to address a data bottleneck problem. The access to account (XS2A) rule introduced by the revised EU Payment Service Directive (PSD2) is worth of attention as it mandates banks to provide access to customer account data to all authorized third payment service providers. If properly implemented, the XS2A rule may unlock competition in retail financial markets by mitigating consumer disengagement and information asymmetry problems that have traditionally affected retail financial markets. In this respect, as showed by the UK Open Banking experience, supervised application programming interfaces (APIs) standardization is crucial to deliver adequate levels of interoperability.
Consumer inertia and Open Banking
Working Paper
Disclaimer: I'm not the author of the paper, I've added it to the list of WP in order to link it to an event; the authors are detailed below. Authors: Oscar Borgogno and Giuseppe Colangelo Title: Consumer inertia and competition-sensitive data governance: the case of Open Banking Abstract: The issue of consumer disengagement has troubled regulators and policy makers for years, since it undermines the functioning of sound competitive markets by allowing incumbents to enjoy economic supracompetive returns to the detriment of innovation and consumer welfare. The market investigation into the banking industry launched by the UK Competition and Market Authority (CMA) represents an original attempt to tackle the problem through antitrust enforcement. By building on the access-to-account rule enshrined within the European regulatory framework of the revised Payment Service Directive and the most recent developments of FinTech innovation, the CMA has designed a set of measures aimed at addressing some of the structural features causing adverse effects on competition in the retail markets, ultimately paving the way towards Open Banking. The paper highlights the rationales, benefits and potential drawbacks of the UK Open Banking plan, investigating if this regulatory intervention can act as a blueprint for harnessing the competitive potential of data-driven innovation of the financial industry and the digital economy as a whole.
Working groups
- Finance, Law, and Economics
- Political Economy of Europe
Project Organizers
Maria Cecilia del Barrio Arleo
Stefano Di Bucchianico
For questions, the Project Organizers.
YSI Webinar
When Things Don’t Fall Apart - Global financial incoherence and beyond
June 24 2020, 16:30
We are glad to announce our forth webinar in the series 'Central bankers and new banking paradigms: Dialogue with Andrea Enria'. Although our event had to be suspended, we decided to continue with the webinar series in order to keep on exploring interesting topics related to the global financial architecture. We are thrilled to have Prof Ilene Grabel with us, who will present her latest book and provide us with further reflections on financial governance in the era of Covid-19.
When Things Don’t Fall Apart: Global Financial Governance and Developmental Finance in an Age of Productive Incoherence (The MIT Press, 2017) won the 2019 European Association for Evolutionary Political Economy Myrdal Prize, the 2019 Int'l Studies Association International Political Economy Best Book Award, & the 2018 British Int'l Studies Association International Political Economy Book Prize.
Open access edition of the book available at: https://direct.mit.edu/books/book/3634/When-Things-Don-t-Fall-ApartGlobal-Financial
In When things Don’t Fall Apart, Ilene Grabel makes a simple but controversial claim, based on the work of the eminent social scientist Albert O. Hirschman. Grabel argues that as concerns global financial governance and development finance we are now in a period that she calls productive incoherence. Unlike the Keynesian period of the middle 20th century and the neoliberal period that followed, the current conjuncture lacks an overarching theoretical framework to guide financial governance. In its absence, Grabel maps the proliferation of institutional innovation at the national, regional, and transregional levels. These experiments are grounded in a spirit of Hirschmanian pragmatism rather than Keynesian or neoclassical dogmatism. They are ad hoc, often limited in scope, and even inconsistent with each other. They are in that sense incoherent. The book’s novel normative claim is that this incoherence is productive. It is allowing for new institutional and policy innovations that are contributing to a pluripolar financial governance architecture that is more robust and offers greater opportunities for problem solving and experimentation than the coherent architecture it is displacing.
Grabel substantiates these claims with empirically-rich case studies that explore the effects of recent crises on established and new networks of financial governance (such as the G-20); transformations within the IMF; institutional innovations in liquidity support and project finance from the national to the transregional levels; and the “rebranding” of capital controls. Grabel acknowledges, however, that the incoherent transformations underway also pose grave risks. She considers these risks in the concluding chapter of the book.
Grabel will also reflect on the constructive and destructive aspects of incoherence in the global financial arena in the era of Covid-19.
Speaker's short bio
Ilene Grabel is a Distinguished University Professor at the University of Denver and Professor of International Finance at the Josef Korbel School of International Studies of the University of Denver (USA). She co-directs the graduate program in Global Finance, Trade, and Economic Integration at the Korbel School. Her research and teaching interests focus on the political economy of international financial policy, institutions, and financial flows; global financial governance; global, regional, and transregional financial architectures; and finance and economic development.
See more of Prof Grabel's journal articles, book chapters and working papers here: https://ilenegrabel.com/journal_book_papers/
For those that would like to participate but are not currently registered in the Young Scholars Directory, feel free to contact cecilia.delbarrio@unitn.it to get the link ahead of the event.
We look forward to seeing you online! Orsola, Stefano, and Cecilia
Recording
You must login to see recordings from this webinar.
Time & Date
Start: June 24 2020, 16:30*
Duration: 60 minutes
*Time is displayed in your local time zone (Africa/Abidjan).
Presenters
Maria Cecilia del Barrio Arleo
Frankfurt, Germany
Orsola Costantini
New York, United States
Stefano Di Bucchianico
Ilene Grabel
Share invitation
Join us for a Webinar!
Topic: When Things Don’t Fall Apart - Global financial incoherence and beyond
Time: June 24 2020, 16:30 (Timezone: Africa/Abidjan)
Join from PC, Mac, Linux, iOS or Android: https://ysi.ineteconomics.org/project/5e1de57a17c9946aa4834265/event/5eda3d72700fb850c843e545